Bush cannot withold science on global warming


Bush administration violates law: Environmentalists win White House suit



Press Release - Federal Court Ruling


Associated Press/August 22, 2007 
- A federal judge ordered the Bush administration
to issue two scientific reports on global warming, siding with
environmentalists who sued the White House for failing to produce the


>U.S. District Court Judge Saundra Armstrong ruled Tuesday that the Bush
administration had violated a 1990 law when it failed to meet deadlines
for an updated U.S. climate change research plan and impact assessment.


Armstrong set a March 1, 2008 deadline for the administration to issue the
research plan, which is meant to guide federal research on climate
change. Federal law calls for an updated plan every three years, she
said. The last one was issued in 2003.

[Strategic Plan for the US Climate Change Science Program 2003]


The judge set a May 31, 2008 deadline to produce a national assessment
containing the most recent scientific data on global warming and its
projected effects on the country's environment, economy and public
health. The government is required to complete a national assessment
every four years, the judge ruled.


The last one was issued by the Clinton administration in 2000.


The administration had claimed that it had discretion over how and when it
produced the reports - an argument the judge rejected Tuesday.


"The defendants are wrong," Armstrong wrote in the 38-page ruling. "Congress
has conferred no discretion upon the defendants as to when they will
issue revised Research Plans and National Assessments."


The plaintiffs - the Center for Biological Diversity, Friends of the Earth
and Greenpeace - said the ruling was a rebuke to an administration that
has systematically denied and suppressed information on global warming.


"It's a huge victory holding the administration accountable for its attempts
to suppress science," said Kassie Siegel, an attorney for the Center
for Biological Diversity, one of the plaintiffs that filed suit in Oakland federal court in November.


Bush administration officials were still reviewing the ruling Tuesday and
could not comment on it directly, said Kristin Scuderi, a spokeswoman
for the U.S. Office of Science and Technology Policy, which was named
in the lawsuit.


the administration is complying with the law, Scuderi said. The U.S.
Climate Change Science Program is working on 21 separate reports on
global warming's projected effects on the U.S and has started to
prepare a new research plan, she said.



On the Net:


U.S. Climate Change Science Program: http://www.climatescience.gov/ / http://www.climatescience.gov/about/default.htm



Center for Biological Diversity: http://www.biologicaldiversity.org/






Judge Orders Bush Administration to Issue Global Warming Report / Bush Ordered to Release Overdue Climate-Change Plan, Assessment
Bloomberg - Aug 21, 2007
Karen Gullo Aug. 21 (Bloomberg) -- The Bush administration violated US
law by failing to produce a study on the impact of global warming ...


Court Rules Against Bush Administration in Global Warming Case ...
Center for Biological Diversity (press release), AZ - Aug 21, 2007
Calif.– The Bush administration was rebuked today by a federal judge
for suppressing scientific reports on the impacts of global warming ...


Judge: White House Must Release Reports
FOX News - 14 hours ago
TERENCE CHEA, AP Writer SAN FRANCISCO — A federal judge ordered the
Bush administration to issue two scientific reports on global warming ...


Judge: Bush officials broke law by not reporting on warming
San Francisco Chronicle,  USA - Aug 21, 2007
16:32 PDT OAKLAND -- The Bush administration has violated a 2004
congressional deadline for presenting the latest scientific research
about global warming ...


Judge: Overdue warming reports violate law
Arizona Daily Star, AZ - 18 hours ago
The Bush administration violated US law by missing deadlines to produce a study on the impact of global warming, now as much as two years overdue ...


Judge orders White House to produce global warming reports
KESQ, CA - Aug 21, 2007
- August 21, 2007 8:54 PM ET SAN FRANCISCO (AP) - A federal judge has
sided with environmentalists who sued the White House and is now
ordering the Bush ...